Sport news, read across sources

Home / Football

Sunderland beat Chelsea 1-0 after two penalty calls, one given and one not

Enzo Le Fee's penalty gave Sunderland a first league win in eight games. Xabi Alonso's verdict on his Chelsea side, and what the numbers say about their road form.

Football 4 min read

Photo: Arne Müseler, CC BY-SA 3.0 de, via Wikimedia Commons / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 de

Sunderland’s first league win in eight games came from one decision by the referee and one that he did not make. Enzo Le Fee scored from the penalty spot in the 36th minute at the Stadium of Light on 8 November, and that was enough to beat Chelsea 1-0, according to the Press Association.

The win lifted Sunderland off the bottom of the table, though they stayed in the relegation zone. Their previous league victory had been against Fulham in August. For Chelsea it was a fourth league defeat of the season and a fall out of the top four.

The two calls

The match turned on two incidents about ten minutes apart, as AFP and Flashscore both describe them.

In the first, midway through the half, Cole Palmer went down under a challenge from Luke O’Nien. Referee Jarred Gillett and the video assistant ruled that the contact was outside the box, so there was no penalty. Chelsea felt aggrieved.

In the second, Levi Colwill fouled Brian Brobbey inside the area and Gillett pointed to the spot. Le Fee sent goalkeeper Mike Penders the wrong way. Colwill was replaced by Estevao at half-time.

Alonso’s reaction, quoted by AFP, was careful. On the Palmer incident he said he had not seen it but had been told that “there was a chance that it would be a fair penalty and it could have been given.” On the result itself he was blunt: “I think we didn’t deserve more than probably one point, the game was really close.”

Sunderland’s week

The context makes the win more unusual. AFP says Sunderland’s manager, Regis Le Bris, was under pressure after a 2-0 home loss to Dinamo Zagreb in the Europa League earlier that week. The Press Association adds that Le Bris made eight changes from that game, and that Chemsdine Talbi made his first league start of the season.

Rotating eight players three days after a defeat is a gamble. It worked, at least once. Flashscore also records that this was Sunderland’s third straight league win over Chelsea, something it says had not happened since 2001, and only their second Premier League win this season.

Brobbey’s part deserves a note. Flashscore says he could not keep an early six-yard volley on target, and then won the penalty that decided the match. A forward who misses the easy chance and then draws the foul is still the difference.

What Alonso said about the problem

The more useful part of AFP’s report is Alonso’s description of what went wrong. He said Chelsea lacked patience, quality and creativity against a low block, and needed to be more consistent in moving the ball. He was also without Joao Pedro, and AFP says Palmer and Morgan Rogers were largely contained. Chelsea had most of the possession after the break, the Press Association notes, but struggled to create clear chances.

Flashscore lists the ones they did have. Romeo Lavia shot narrowly wide from about 30 yards, Wilson Isidor was denied by Penders, Geovany Quenda and Danny Welbeck came close, and Welbeck had a late chance in stoppage time that he did not convert.

The road record

Two numbers frame Chelsea’s season. AFP says this was their fourth league defeat in 10 games under Alonso, leaving them fifth and two points outside the top four. Flashscore says they have won only two of 11 competitive road matches.

Those are not the figures of a side in crisis. The same table has Chelsea two points from the top four. They are, however, the figures of a team that struggles to break teams down away from home when its best forward is missing and the opposition sits deep. That is what Alonso described in his own words.

Sunderland, for their part, now have two league wins and a way to play when they are the underdog: defend, win one set piece or one foul, and hold on. It is not a method that scales over a season, and they remain in the bottom three. As a template for a single afternoon, it worked.

Sources

  1. Press Association (via Express & Star): Enzo Le Fee penalty sinks Chelsea as Sunderland end winless run expressandstar.com
  2. AFP (via New Straits Times): Chelsea suffer controversial defeat at Sunderland nst.com.my
  3. Flashscore: Le Fee penalty fires Sunderland to much-needed triumph against Chelsea flashscore.com